Testing in Anaconda's Benny Goodman Park shows wide contamination — highest in kids' sand box

Source: http://mtstandard.com, May 25, 2017
By: Susan Dunlap

A children’s sand box in Anaconda’s Benny Goodman Park has exposed children to arsenic and lead well above levels the Environmental Protection Agency considers safe.

Anaconda-Deer Lodge County opted to have its own technical consultant, Water and Environmental Technologies, sample 55 spots in Benny Goodman Park last month. The county released the test sampling to The Montana Standard Wednesday. WET found that only four of the 55 test pits came back clean.
The most concerning spot was “hole 18,” which is a sand box where children play. Within the top two inches of the soil — likely the most accessible spot in the park since kids dig in a sand box — arsenic levels tested at 725 parts per million. Lead within the top two inches tested at 817 parts per million.
EPA did not comment on the park by press time. But Montana Superfund director Joe Vranka said in a previous email that Benny Goodman Park was sampled for arsenic sometime between 2002 and 2010. EPA had the park tested to a depth of two inches.
“Based on sample results (in the early 2000s), no action was required,” said Vranka.
But according to WET’s testing, 16 spots in the park tested high for arsenic in the top two inches of the soil. WET’s tests show 15 areas in the park where lead is above what EPA considers safe in the top two inches of the soil.
The area where the arsenic level was the highest in the top two inches of soil in the park was the sand box, WET’s sample results show.

The highest level of lead came back, at 1,118 parts per million, at a depth of two to six inches, just under a tree in the middle of the park.
The highest arsenic level in the park, at 1,285 parts per million, at a depth of six to 12 inches, is in the sand box.
Arsenic is a known carcinogen. Lead exposure in children can cause learning and behavioral problems, brain damage, developmental delays and other physical and mental problems, according to EPA’s website. Although lead exposure is a concern for people of all ages, young children, from newborn to seven years old, are the most at risk.
EPA has determined that safe levels of arsenic in the soil for Anaconda is 250 parts per million and safe levels of lead are 400 parts per million in the soil. EPA says it based those levels on laboratory tests. But critics of EPA’s cleanup in Anaconda point out that the Smelter City has one of the highest levels for arsenic at Superfund sites across the nation.
EPA’s level of 400 parts per million for lead in Anaconda is “generally considered an appropriate screening level for soil lead,” according to EPA’s website.
EPA began retesting Anaconda’s soil for lead last summer at greater depths — up to 12 inches — which is deeper than the federal agency was willing to go in the early 2000s when it began the soil cleanup for arsenic. EPA project manager Charlie Coleman previously told The Standard the agency thought it would catch lead when it cleaned up for arsenic, but EPA found, over time, that that did not fully hold true.
Now, EPA is planning to remediate more than 1,000 properties in Anaconda for excessive lead in the soil. And Atlantic Richfield has offered the first 500 property owners $1,000 each to agree not to sue over the cleanup.
That residents have been living with high levels of lead in their soil for nearly two generations since Anaconda’s Washoe Smelter shut down in 1980 has caused concern for many residents.
Anaconda-Deer Lodge County Chief Executive Bill Everett said the test results have made the county aware of what’s in the community’s soil.
Elizabeth Erickson, one of the principal owners of WET, said risk to arsenic and lead is based on exposure. Kids spend more time in their back yards and less time in a park. That makes the park’s sand box “a little different level of risk.”
“But, yes, we’re concerned,” she added.
Atlantic Richfield’s Houston-based spokesperson Jason Ryan said, via email, that it received the county’s sampling results on Benny Goodman Park Tuesday. The company has offered to replace the contaminated sand with new sand.
“The rest of the park will be further investigated and remediated, as necessary, under direction from the regulatory agencies,” Ryan said via email.

Ryan said how quickly the removal and replacement of the sand in the sand box happens is up to the county. Everett said he hopes to have the sand removed and replaced before the end of the week but he is not going to close off the park.
Ryan did not give a time frame on how soon Atlantic Richfield will retest the park. Because WET’s test was a “quick hit,” type of test, Atlantic Richfield will do more testing.
Everett said he hopes to see the park re-tested and fully cleaned this summer, but a cleanup might not happen until next summer.
Vranka said in the previous email that new sampling will be conducted to a depth of 12 inches. Vranka said previously that if lead and arsenic is high in the park up to 12 inches in the soil, “the full extent of the waste will be remediated.”
But Everett asked that the park be sampled up to 18 inches. It is not yet clear how EPA will respond to the request to sample the additional six inches of soil. WET’s testing shows eight spots where lead is high within the 12 to 18 inches of the soil.
According to EPA, the natural amount of arsenic in Anaconda’s soil is likely around 25 parts per million. EPA says the soil is so disturbed in Anaconda, it had to go outside the area to test arsenic in soil in other areas in Montana to reach that conclusion.
Everett requested the soil be sampled in Benny Goodman Park once the county needed to appropriate $60,000 this spring to replace a 70-year-old sprinkler system in the park. Because recent test samples in nearby residents’ yards are showing high levels of lead, Everett said he felt some concern the park might have high levels of contamination, too.
So the county put off using money for the sprinkler system until the park could get tested. EPA agreed to let the county do its own testing.
Everett said he expects to know more and whether the park should be closed to residents after he talks to EPA. That is expected to happen later this week.
“They are the experts on what is safe and what is not,” said Everett.

Find a Broker or Underwriter

Search by product, location or name
https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/best-insurance/best-wholesale-brokers-usa--5star-wholesale-brokers-and-mgas-478736.aspxhttps://www.newsweek.com/rankings/most-loved-workplaces-america-2023https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/best-insurance/best-insurance-companies-to-work-for-in-the-us--top-insurance-employers-2023-453773.aspx

Please Update Your Browser

Unfortunately Microsoft is no longer providing support or security fixes for your web browser. RT Specialty values the safety and security of its clients’ data, and as such this site requires the use of a modern web browser. To update your web browser, please see the links below. If you have any questions or would like additional information, please email info@rtspecialty.com or call (312) 784-6001.

Firefox Firefox Chrome Chrome IE Internet Explorer Edge Microsoft Edge